Keating v. FERC

Court cases

114 F.3d 1265 (D.C. Cir. 1997)

Issue. Can FERC rely on objectives contained in a forest plan to determine whether a proposed project will be consistent with the purposes for which the national forest was created?
Holding. FERC may not rely on a Forest Service evaluation, as contained in a forest plan, to determine whether a project would be consistent with the purposes for which the national forest was created. The “consistency” provision contained in FPA § 4(e)
requires FERC to ask and answer 2 questions: (1) for what purposes was the Inyo
National Forest created, and (2) would the proposed project interfere with or be
inconsistent with those purposes.

Contributed by:

Hydropower Reform Coalition

 

View PDF

Related resource

Court cases

Escondido Mutual Water Co. v. La Jolla Band of Mission Indians

Issue 1. Can FERC reject the Secretary’s 4(e) conditions?

See all resources